Friday, May 23, 2025

Flatlined aquaculture production and a small fragment of west coast potential

 May 20, 2025


To: Federal and Provincial Ministers of Agriculture and Fisheries

Dear Ministers:

On behalf of Canada’s seafood farming community, we thank you for your work and your commitment to your provinces and to Canada. As leaders in the aquaculture sector, we commit ourselves to working with you to create lasting value and flourishing communities through our sector across Canada.

The future of seafood development in Canada and across the world is dependent on human ingenuity to find new ways to responsibly create value from our oceans, to innovate to produce more, secure and affordable seafood to support Canadians and the world.

We have a special responsibility in Canada with some of the greatest biophysical capacity on the planet. With highly skilled people, and many coastal communities waiting for new opportunities and renewal, precision farming of our waters is a unique blessing for Canada.

It is time to move beyond Canada’s mediocre performance. For over twenty years Canada has Flatlined in aquaculture production growth while using only a small fragment of our potential. We need a new vision and government leadership to support us to the next level of production and excellence in aquaculture production. You are the leaders that can and must be bold to achieve this.

We ask you to undertake a pathway that allows for a new approach to aquaculture development in Canada. We propose the following areas of action to you as the foundations for a new springtime in seafood development and coastal community revitalization.

1) Science Must Be the Foundation

Science must be re-established as foundational for aquaculture development. A re-commitment to objective scientific advice as the foundation for policy decisions is necessary. All human activity has some degree of environmental risk, and there is no such thing as zero risk. Putting off economic development risks the health of people, families and communities. Governments must be clear on acceptable levels of environmental risk to make predictable and reasonable decisions for project development.

2) The BC “Open Net Pen” Ban Must Be Removed

The 2024 federal decision to ban salmon farming net pens by 2029 is scientifically, economically and technologically irresponsible. It has cast an investment chill on all of Canada and we are seeing its negative influence around the world. As salmon farming investment decisions in BC for 2029 are approaching quickly, the ban must be removed urgently in favour of a clear performance-based pathway that establishes stabilization, future growth and attracts investment in innovation and new technologies.

3) Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC) Must be the Federal Aquaculture Champion

DFO is a regulator and habitat protector. It is not equipped to support a modern, growth-oriented farming sector. It is time for a change. AAFC must be named the lead federal department for sector development, while DFO and CFIA continue to be regulators of the sector. Aquaculture must finally be included in federal legislation as a farming activity consistent with international definitions.

4) Modernize Shellfish Sector Management and Risk Supports

The shellfish aquaculture sector holds significant economic, environmental, and food security potential across Canada. However, its growth is constrained by outdated federal oversight, particularly under the Canadian Shellfish Sanitation Program (CSSP), and by the sector’s exclusion from essential risk management tools available to other forms of food production. A modernized approach is needed — one that ensures effective, coordinated delivery of public health protections while also enabling access to government-industry programs that provide stability and resilience for producers.

To move this forward, we request federal support for a pilot crop insurance program for shellfish aquaculture in Prince Edward Island, with the goal of informing a national approach to business risk management program access for shellfish farmers in all producing provinces.

We ask you: provide a positive signal that aquaculture is an important part of Canada’s future and together begin building a united vision for this future. 

For our part, we will increase our efforts to build public trust and constantly improve our practices. We can together build a sector that leads the world with job creation, skilled workers, Indigenous economic and reconciliation opportunities, low-carbon, healthy and affordable home-grown protein production, and renewed coastal communities

This is an exciting time and challenge. The time is now for positive and lasting change to benefit your provinces and all of Canada.

Sincerely,




Read Native Articles, Business Features

Read Native Articles, Business Features
Pathway to progress for all Canadians

All-time Reader's Choice

Search 100s of McColl Magazine articles

Labels

195MWh 2010 Olympics 2011 2017 2025 4.84 million BPD 47 AI AI Insights (for Grok mentions) Aboriginal Aquaculture Aboriginal Security Service Aboriginal Title Aboriginal Woman of Distinction Accredited Actor Adminstration Building Al Gore Alberta Alberta Energy Alert Bay Aluminum boats Angelique Merasty Levac Angry Anna Kendrick Annual Meeting Apprentice April Arms Embargo Art Associate Biologist B.C. B.C. Aboriginal Achievement Awards B.C. Coast B.C. Forestry B.C. Tourism B.C. fisheries BC BC Aquaculture BC Coast BC HYDRO BC Salmon Farmers Babies Basketball Beau Dick Ben Bankas Bioenergy Solutions Birch Bark Biting Birch Bark Canoe Birth bark biting Birthrate Black Market Bob Rae Body count Bones of Crows British Columbia Business Category CBSA CGWA CMT Research CRC of BC Campbell River Canada Canada/US Canada/US trade Canadian Canadian Energy Trade Canadian Politics Canadian comedy Canoe Carving Canwell Capilano Carney Carpenter Carpenters Carpentry Carver Carver/Artist Carving Carving totem poles Cedar Bark Weaving Charlie Kirk Chief Clarence Louie Chief John Henderson Chinese Canadian history Christmas Movie Churchill Climate Climate Policies Cloudworks Energy Coal Coalition Coastal First Nations College of The Rockies Comedy Community Benefit Agreements Conference Conflict Construction Convention Covid Crawling Culture Current Events Daily Commentary Dangerfield Mack McColl Dave Chappelle David Garrick Davos Deep Bay Direct Action Diving Domestric violence Driverless cars EV Mandate Economic Development Edmonton Edmonton Oilers Education Egypt Ehattesaht Elbow Up Election Election 2025 Elon Musk Enbridge Energy Policy Entertainment Equalization Eternal Eternity European FDI FNNBOA Father Feb 2003 Feeding Fernwood 2Nite Finance First Nation First Nations First Nations Consortium First Nations Drum First Nations Forestry Fish Farm Fisheries Forensic Nurse Future GIS Training GROK Gabriola Island Gail Murray Gasoline Geoexchange Geothermal Global Security Grace Dove Green Energy Greenpeace Ground Water Haida Gwaii energy Hamas Hamas celebrates Hanson Island Happy Holiday Heating Hemp Highway 16 Housing Inspections Hudson's Bay Human Rights Huu Ay Aht Hydro INAC Ice Age Independent Independent Journalism Indian Reservation Indigenous Art Indigenous Artist Indigenous Land Rights Indigenous Reconciliation Indigenous artists Indigenous economic development Indigenous leader Indigenous skill development Indigenous sovereignty Indigenous tourism Innergex Inside Passage Instruction Interprovincial relations Invention Iskut River Israel J-Leg Jane Ash Poitras Japan John Candy John Wick John Wick 4 Jordan Peterson Journalism K'Moks Kelowna Kentucky Bourbon Kerri Dick Kiteboarding Kitimat Kitimat Valley Institute Klahoose First Nation Klahowya Klemtu Ksan Historic Site Kwaguilth LNG Lateral Violence Leaders Leaders debate Liberal Liberal Leadership Liberal leadership race Lil'Wat Nation Logging Love Lower Mainland MPB MPB and decadent forests Mack McColl Management Manitoba Manufacture Marcus Alfred Marine services Martin Mull Max Chickite McColl Magazine McColl's Dialogue on Development Melanie Joly Middle East Middle East Conflict Millbrook Chief Lawrence Millbrook First Nation Modular Morgroup Management Mortgage Musician Mustang NBCC NDP NHL 2025-26 Season NWCC Namgis Nanaimo Native Art Neck Point Net Zero New Brunswick New Energy New Years North Pacific North Vancouver Northeast B.C. Northern Canada Northern Gateway Northern Manitoba Sector Council Northern Ontario Northern Saskatchewan Northwest B.C. Northwest Pacific Canada Nova Scotia Numchuks Nunavut Nuu Chah Nulth Oil Field Security Oil exploration Order of Canada Organized Crime Osoyoos Outdoor Adventure Trainingf Pacific First Nations Pacific Northwest Canada Pat Alfred Memorial Potlatch Pauly Shore Pearl Harris Personal property Pierre Poilievre Pipeline Poilievre Politics Port Port of Churchill Port of Prince Rupert Port services Potlatch Pre-fabricated. Housing Premier Danielle Smith President Trump Prince George Prince Rupert Protest Public Policy Quebec Quebec Policies Quebec Politics RIP ROR power RPF Randy Dakota Rapture Palooza. Comedy Reconciliation Recycle Red Seal Reduced oil consumption Religious Freedom Replacement Replacement birth rate Resort Resource Management Resources North Reuse Run-of-river hydro SCTV SNL Salmon Salmon Restoration Satellites Satire Scallops Science Scurry Shoreline Carving Silviculture Singh Skiing Skilled Labour Skills Social Justice Solar Energy Son SpaceX Spirit Bear Squamish First Nation Squirrel Squirrels St'at'mx Nation Stephen Miller Story Anthology Suez Canal Suffer Summer vacation Sustainable Forestry T'Sou-ke First Nation Tariffs Tax Revolt Technical training Technology The Revenant Threads of Life Tidal Totem Poles Transportation Trout Trudeau Trudeau resigns Trump TrumpvsMSM Tug boats U.S.-Canada UBCIC UK US Politics Urban Urban Indigenous Canada Urban Poverty Used tires VIU Graduate VIU Shellfish Research Vancouver 2010 Olympics Vancouver Island Vocational training Volunteer WEF WFCA Warcanoes Washington State We Wai Kai West Coast Western Canada Western Separation Wild ride Wild salmon Wildfire Winter habitat Women in forestry Wood fuel Woodland Cree Work Safety acrobatic agriculture agro-forestry annual fund raiser aquaculture archeology artisans assassination autonomous vehicles baby bank bio-mass bioenergy biomass biomass energy broken building burden careers certification challenge citizen journalism clouds collapse commercial community control cortez Island crime crisis decadent forest decadent forests delusional disaster disorder doubtful economic development economy end corruption energy entourage environmental management failure families fanatics fascists fiat currency film & TV flooring food banks forestry free speech friend function government hello homes housing housing standards hubris hydropower indigenous infant insurance investment january journalism kakistocracy land management lead blown leasehold liberals mind minority mismanagment mountain bike northern B.C. northern B.C.. oil & gas oil and gas old Hazelton pellet personal injury pighead police recruits political population falling prescribed burns projected BBD promises public safety referrals regulations rubber famine run-of-river run-ot-river safety salmon farming security services social capital solar stick story by Mack McColl tariffs taxes territory terrorist sympathizers torrefaction trade trade war training travel treasured memories tree planters tugboat tyranny unprecedented veterinary windpower woke wood pellets woodpecker world world population